October 15th, 2012

Lisa’s Pre-Internet Identity Theft Story

4 Comments | Twitter | |


id theft

When I started college, the internet wasn’t the machine it is today. You couldn’t apply for a credit card online. It could only be done over the phone, via snail mail or on a college campus, where credit card companies would set up tables and advertise to new, wide-eyed college students.

Sure enough, I was one of those new college students who knew nothing about credit cards, and I applied for my very first card.

At first, I overspent, and because I wasn’t making the income to support my spending, I incurred finance charges and late fees. Once it happened and I learned my lesson, I became frugal and careful with my spending. I barely used my credit card and only spent cash.

When it all went wrong

A few years later I decided to travel overseas for a few months to volunteer teach the English language to elementary students in Israel. Little did I know the troubling situation that was waiting for me at home. After a few weeks back in the states, I start receiving phone calls from debt collectors that bills of mine weren’t paid. Naturally, I was totally confused — these calls came from companies who I never opened a credit card with!

Since these companies had all my personal information, I began investigating who opened these credit cards. The address used was an ex-boyfriend’s mother. Fuming, and knowing that confronting the ex wouldn’t get me anywhere, I knew I had to take matters into my own hands. I did some more digging and found out that the credit cards were opened the day I left for my volunteer work. In order to get out of paying the bills, I had to show airplane tickets and my passport as proof that I wasn’t in the country.

Seriously? Was I a victim of identity theft even before the Internet? Yes! And to make matters worse, a person whom I trusted stole it. Instead of attempting to get the money or have her admit wrong (from past experiences, that would never happen) I sought outside help.

The long road to recovery

First, I contacted the creditors to explain the situation and why I would not be paying the bills. Luckily, one of the customer service representatives listened, believed me and pointed me in the right direction. She put me in contact with their legal department, who guided me during the process and helped me get the debt out of my name and transferred to the “rightful” owner’s responsibility.

They had me file a police report as an identity theft victim with my local police department. Because the thief was my ex-boyfriend’s mother, I wasn’t sure about giving her up. But ultimately, I gave them her information.

This woman could have ruined my credit for life!

Next I had to make copies of everything – my passport, country entrance stamps, country exit stamps, airplane tickets, traveler check receipts and my legal home address. The thief used her home address, which made it a lot easier to prove my innocence. The copies and police report had to be certified mailed to the legal department. Then once the creditors received my documents, I followed up. Within six weeks, the credit card debt was no longer my responsibility.

But it didn’t end there…

The history of the two cards she took out still showed up on my credit reports as defaulted debt and company charge-offs. I sent dispute letters to all three credit reporting agencies, with the explanation and a copy of the agreement letters from the creditors. Unfortunately, I had to hire a legal firm that specialized in clearing up credit histories to get the debt off of my record. A few months later, after the firm consistently contacted the three reporting agencies, the negative records were deleted from my credit history. In total, it took a year and a half to get the debt off of my credit history. As a precaution, I placed a seven-year protection on my reports and accounts so any new application for credit or even a large charge on my current credit cards, I would receive an immediate phone call to be proactive.

What you can do

Credit reporting agencies offer a wealth of resources online to keep your credit safe. If you’re a victim of identity theft, don’t let the thief win. Be proactive, add a protection or credit freeze on your reports and turn the tables on the robber.

Lisa Weinberger is the Director of Content Promotion for Bankrate, Inc. bringing more than 15 years of consulting experience combining search (SEO), content and social. Most of her day consists of training and supporting enterprise internal teams about the driving force of content to rank organically in search.

Lisa leads the brainstorming, content creation strategies and promotion plans using data and various content formats to promote and gain reach. When Lisa is not obsessing about maintaining rankings, she can be found by the beach.

Follow Credit Karma!

Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/CreditKarma

Twitter: http://twitter.com/creditkarma

YouTube: http://www.youtube.com/creditkarma

Subscribe to the Credit Karma Blog


Disclaimer: All information posted to this site was accurate at the time of its initial publication. Efforts have been made to keep the content up to date and accurate. However, Credit Karma does not make any guarantees about the accuracy or completeness of the information provided. For complete details of any products mentioned, visit bank or issuer website.


  1. I had a similar thing happen – identity theft by a family member. Although in my case, it was my (then) wife, and I didn’t follow-through. The credit card bills were going to my mother-in-laws address.
    If that was 6 years ago – is it even worth the effort in getting it “fixed” on my credit reports? I have an audio recording of her admitting to her using my name and getting a credit card, and it being identity theft.
    We recently got divorced – and I should have seen the signs from 6 years ago because it was all about hidden actions behind my back and it just never stopped. Luckily, that was the only identity theft incident (from her).

    Taka at 7:23 am on October 16, 2012
  2. Identity theft among family is more common than you would think. My mom filled out a credit app sent by mail and even went over the limit and missed a payment. When I found out, I transferred the balance, took out a student loan and paid off half immediately. Now I am debt free other than a mortgage and my credit score is excellent. Luckily it was a low limit so little damage done and I was living with her for free which helped me pay it off.

    Jimbo at 6:22 am on October 17, 2012
  3. I had identity theft happen to me about 5 years ago. I was on vacation visiting my family for Thanksgiving. I went to Atem to get money and my account said $0. I had just been paid and knew I should of had money. Anyway, after that experience I have been so cautious of my credit cards, bank accounts, signature, etc. To make things safer for me, I bought a identity theft protection stamp. Everyone should have a stamp like this. If anyone is interested check outhttp://www.allprostamps.com/Pages/IdentityTheftProtectionStamps.aspx. I hope this helps.

    Wendy at 9:55 am on October 25, 2012

Enter your comment